Rhetorica
Sleepless Scribe
Anthologica Universe Atlas / Users / Rhetorica

universes
Miscellanea This universe is a general container for creations that do not belong to a universe or alternate history, such as auxlangs.
Reference This is the Reference Desk project. Contribute information on natlangs, how to conlang, and how to use the site (and other software) here. If you'd like to contribute to the reference desk, please contact someone from the Site Staff or ask in the forum thread, and you will be added to the user group. See also the reference desk forum thread for discussion on what work is actively being done.
Testiverse This is a demonstration universe meant to show off Anthologica's universe management features. This text only appears in universe listings and on user profile pages.
languages
Black Maldisian Maldisian as spoken in Umami and outlying regions.
Proto-Testian This is an example Test Language.
Yathalon

Samantics

Tenuresse oblige

University politics. Woo.
read more · 4 days ago

The Interrogation of the Fisherman

He had always been fond of flying animals. They made the long, hot days out on the raft more interesting, especially around noon when the glade was mostly quiet. Once he had befriended a raven—loosely speaking—by feeding it some of the undergrown crayfish he caught that he knew wouldn’t sell well at market. Its personality was much different from the usual bat-winged tigvi kept by rich women in the cities; less capricious, more patient. Admirable, in its own way. It had vanished a few days later, but not before returning the favour by depositing a clutch of worms directly into his tackle box as it flew off. How he envied its freedom. […]
read more · a year ago

Don'tscovery

Failures, summarized:

Klingons—

- Needless Klingon redesign. They're not Drow. Stop making them wear Lolth gear. Somehow the Vulcans survived unscathed, showing that, no, it wasn't a 'let's have plausibly alien aliens' thing.
- Useless Bat'leth. The Discovery version can't be used to parry or disarm the opponent, and provides no protection for the fingers. No one thought this through.
- T'Kuvma continues to talk after his upper spine is severed.
[…]
read more · a year ago
More...

Ex foris

? Rhetorica Sleepless Scribe
posts: 1226
, Kelatetía: Dis, Major Belt 1
message
quoting Izambri, Duke, the Findible League:
Bèrs tant aget Aléspanikarha, Amídtale Hiarmentnicatze. Al(e)– im lhaonze a menaveu è lheraimí te se lamne èu ringlia.
Aléspanikarha is a pretty word, Rhetorica. I guess that al(e)– stands for “no, not” and that the language is Lilitika.

Zú—alé- + Hispanía + -ika + -arha. Lilitika Ketalàn vóe, dúrafa sotana deke-Doisseia.
Yes—not + Spain + way-of + ACC.F.SING. It's Nomad's Lilitika, the last pre-settlement argolect.
in thread: Translat-o-matic
? Rhetorica Sleepless Scribe
posts: 1226
, Kelatetía: Dis, Major Belt 1
message
Not sure about the handling of Germanic languages. It seems to me they'd survive better on the periphery, like in Britain and Scandinavia, rather than in the heart of the continent, much as the Celtic languages survived in insular environments IRL. German would probably have been an endangered language at this point: the invaders would be arriving in Europe at a time when the Holy Roman Empire was at its maximum extent, and Latin was at maximum prestige, so only peasants spoke MHG at the time (not OHG—that would've transitioned mid-11th millennium due to a major sound shift.) Remember, Mozart's operas (some 500 years later) were considered against the grain because they were in German.

(Alternatively, you may be subtly trying to block Rome proper from expanding into Germania when it did. Why not go the whole way and make Basque country cover the whole Iberian, then?)

Apologies if any of the above is eye-rollingly obvious. I have no clue what your credentials are when it comes to Germanic languages.
? Rhetorica Sleepless Scribe
posts: 1226
, Kelatetía: Dis, Major Belt 1
message
quoting con quesa, Layperson, California:
Also I reject your claim that a language having /ɾ/ as it's only liquid is "weeby". Lots of languages lack /l/.

Sure—but these two statements can coexist. The tongue-in-cheek insinuation comes down to a matter of the motivation for only including one liquid/approximant/trill/etc. As I understand it, the Berber languages are generally pretty rich in this area, so the inspiration isn't immediately apparent.

I also think that talking about how the writing system (if one exists) ought to work is a bit premature,

Divergence between a written language and its spoken counterpart can fossilize etymological relationships that would otherwise be less obvious, e.g. any fluent English speaker could intuit a definition for "complication" by back-forming from "relation", "relate", and "complicate", essentially intuiting what "-tion" does. But the homophone "shun" is of no help at all. (And if that doesn't convince you, just think about how many homophones French has...)

In short, I'm arguing against generating morphemes based purely on phonology. Assuming the culture is highly literate, the written form of the language shouldn't match 1:1, and if we were to, for example, just use IPA to create the language and completely forgo any attempt at an official transliteration, the result would be like Tok Pisin, or some other really immature creole—which is very unlikely to have a phonological inventory as rich as the one proposed.
in thread: Isharian-1

Rhetorica
Sleepless Scribe
last seen: 1 day ago
posts: 1226
Kelatetía

send message
find forum posts

Creator of Lilitika and co-creator of Thet.

I started this site in late 2013 to give the conlanging and conworlding community a specially-tailored way to showcase projects. I don't do quite as much administrating any more, and sometimes I can be scarce because I have so many other big responsibilities, but I try to maintain and improve things whenever I can.

See my profile page elsewhere for more information about me.
notices